Album Review: Weathervanes - Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit

Country is likely the most divisive genre in all of music. While legends like Willie Nelson, Johnny Cash, and Dolly Parton are widely regarded as some of the greatest musicians of all time, many of today’s most popular country artists make headlines for the contrarian and conservative ideologies that constitute their overly simplistic songwriting. While many of the genre’s tropes are predictable and made for the masses, country music’s conventions and aesthetics can also enable artists to engage in incredible storytelling. A historian and adoring fan of the roots of his genre, Jason Isbell’s poetry and hard-hitting lyricism have elevated his music above the noise since he joined the scene. He has described each of his albums as a snapshot in time that captures his current mindset, and the maturity of both his sound and character have been evident with every release. Weathervanes is no different — on Isbell’s newest record, he offers some of the most intricately orchestrated and carefully crafted tracks of his entire career. His masterful storytelling, instrumental choices, and thematic cohesiveness makes this one of the most exciting albums of the year so far.

Each of this album’s lead singles are tasteful examples of all of the flavors it has to offer. “Death Wish” gnashes and grapples with the devastating reality of navigating a relationship with an addict. “Middle of the Morning”, born from the pandemic, explores the existential dread of cabin fever that lockdowns forced on us all. “Save the World” directly confronts the tragedy of school shootings, which unfortunately has to directly affect the way Isbell parents his daughter. “Cast Iron Skillet” creatively and expertly uses common Southern idioms to highlight the backward, brainwashing ideologies that Isbell was taught justify the injustices he saw in the world. Highlights from the project in and of themselves, Weathervanes’ lead singles are complemented by the rest of the album’s tracklisting.

As previously stated, Weathervanes is made up of some of Isbell’s biggest songwriting accomplishments to date. “King of Oklahoma” is a heartbroken and sprawling violin-backed ballad describing the shattered remnants of a failed relationship. “If You Insist” is a tragic track that features the most show-stopping lyrics from the entire album: “My momma spent every day alone / In a house of noise and names / She got so tired putting out fires / She just laid down in the flames.” That line is so effective and chilling that it still gives me goosebumps every time. “White Beretta” narratively recalls Isbell’s experience with navigating an unplanned pregnancy with a previous partner — one of the project’s most understated yet poignant and important political statements. “Miles” is an epic, 7-minute long journey that morphs and evolves over its long runtime, serving as a perfect closer for this album. While not every track here hits its mark, a vast majority are very strong and others are some of the best in Isbell’s discography.

The unclear direction of tracks like “When We Were Close” and “This Ain’t It" left me wanting more from ideals that didn’t feel fully fleshed out, but these shortcomings were more than made up for by the rest of this fantastic project. Jason Isbell’s perspective is a unique and important one in country music — his Americana roots and poetic lyricism are better than any in his field, and Weathervanes may just be his best album yet.

Favorite tracks: “Death Wish”, “King of Oklahoma”, “Strawberry Woman”, “Save the World”, “If You Insist”, “Cast Iron Skillet”, “Volunteer”, “Vestavia Hills” “White Beretta”, “Miles”

SCORE: 8/10