Albums Which Have Earned A Perfect Score (10/10) From Me
Music has become one of the central topics I discuss on this blog. Whether I’m reviewing a new album, making a ranking list of projects which have come out in a given year, or discussing how my taste in music has changed over time, I’ve found that I have a lot to say when discussing music. In one of this blog’s first posts, I outlined my rubric and criteria for scoring albums and giving scores out of ten. After writing over twenty album reviews on this blog, none of the new releases in recent months have received a perfect score of 10/10. I give this score out sparingly and infrequently, reserving it for only the most influential, masterful, and flawless records which also have personal significance to me. While Charli, IGOR, RTJ4, and The Highwomen have all come close on this blog with scores of 9/10, none have earned the highly coveted perfect score. In this post, I’m going to be discussing a few albums which I consider prime examples of albums worthy of such critical acclaim.
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy - Kanye West
This is an album which I grew up listening to on repeat throughout my teenage years. It’s one of the main reasons Kanye West is the artist I’ve listened to most all-time on Spotify. This album defines my favorite Kanye West era: Braggadocious, socially conscious, artistic, and self-reflective. Each beat is luxurious and grandiose, establishing the perfect backdrop for Mr. West and all of the accompanying features to advance the album’s enticing narrative. I think every song belongs exactly where it finds itself on the track-listing, and there is nothing I would change about this project. Tracks like “POWER”, “All Of The Lights”, and “Runaway” were classics the moment they released. The multimodality created by Kanye West’s short film Runaway adds even more to this project’s lore, and because of that, it earns a perfect score.
The Money Store - Death Grips
This isn’t an album I recommend to everyone I meet. Death Grips’ The Money Store is one of the most influential experimental hip-hop albums of all-time, but it’s not for everyone. Its production was far beyond its years upon its release in 2012, and since then, it has proven to be a guideline for industrial and electronic hip-hop releases for a wide range of artists. Tracks like “Get Got”, “I’ve Seen Footage”, and “Hacker” are just as good now as when I was introduced to them years ago, and the chaotic energy this album presents is unparalleled. There’s nothing I could ever change about this album.
Rumours - Fleetwood Mac
This may be the least controversial selection on this list. It’s fairly widely established that Rumours is one of the greatest albums of all-time by any metric. The circumstances in which it was written and recorded were both peculiar and necessary for the creative genius that went into crafting an album consisting of classic after classic. From “Dreams” and “Don’t Stop” to “Go Your Own Way” and “The Chain”, Fleetwood Mac was able to compile some of the most famous and critically acclaimed songs of all-time all on the same project. This album will never get old and will always have a special place in my heart and musical library.
To Pimp A Butterfly - Kendrick Lamar
Kendrick Lamar’s 2015 magnum opus To Pimp A Butterfly is one of the most sonically and thematically masterful hip-hop albums of all-time. Its stellar production, thematic messaging, and creativity make it stand out not only as a great project, but as a very unique record as well. The jazz influences found throughout this album create the perfect backdrop and aesthetic for Kendrick’s intricate delivery of insightful political and socioeconomic commentary. I return to “u”, “Alright”, and “How Much A Dollar Cost” regularly. The usage of the continuing poem throughout this album which culminates in one of the best musical twists ever as Kendrick reveals he has been conversing with Tupac the entire time is still chill-inducing. I will forever love this project, and I’m so glad that Kendrick Lamar was the first concert I attended.
Pure Comedy - Father John Misty
This is my favorite album of all-time. Josh Tillman’s take on an indie folk epic which discusses every element of American society hits on all cylinders for me. Each track is unique and offers relevant and potent critiques on the world around us. Some call this record too heavy or depressing to enjoy listening to, especially repeatedly, but I argue otherwise. The project’s final track, “In Twenty Years Or So”, is able to acknowledge that the world can be difficult, unfair, and make little sense, but that it’s worth living nonetheless with the closing lines “There’s nothing to fear”. I love every song here, but “Pure Comedy”, “Total Entertainment Forever”, “Ballad Of The Dying Man”, “Smoochie”, “So I’m Growing Old On Magic Mountain”, and “In Twenty Years Or So” are some of my favorites. Being able to see Father John Misty perform with my girlfriend after listening to him almost exclusively when meeting and getting to know her was an otherworldly, almost spiritual experience. I even got to touch his bizarrely cold hand from the front row, how cool is that? Pure Comedy epitomizes everything I look for in an album. It has complex lyricism, fantastic and creative production, heartfelt delivery, social commentary, and timeliness. This is the easiest 10/10 I could ever give.
I’m certainly not opposed to giving a perfect score to an album on a new review if any project is able to check all of the boxes and meet the standards set by the projects discussed here. Music is hugely important in my life, and I’m comforted by the fact that returning to these albums will always be an option for me. What are some of your favorite albums of all-time which earn a perfect score from you? Let me know. Thanks for reading.